Home & Kitchen
Best Toasters 2026
Sort: undig score
Ranked by aggregated score from RTINGS, Good Housekeeping, Which? and Trusted Reviews. 2-slice and 4-slice toasters — judged on browning evenness, build quality and features.
RTINGSGood HousekeepingWhich?Trusted ReviewsBBC Good Food + more
#1 Overall 2-slice
Updated August 2026
Sage the 'A Bit More' Toaster
The best all-round toaster — Lift & Look, a countdown timer and 'A Bit More' button for perfect browning
THE undig SCORE — 4 SOURCES, UNTANGLED
88
Out of 100
#2 Overall 2-slice
Updated August 2026
Dualit Classic 2-Slice
The repairable icon — a hand-built, all-metal toaster with replaceable parts made to last decades
THE undig SCORE — 4 SOURCES, UNTANGLED
86
Out of 100
#3 Overall 2-slice
Updated August 2026
Smeg TSF01 2-Slice
The retro design pick — Smeg's 50s-style toaster with even browning and six shade settings
THE undig SCORE — 3 SOURCES, UNTANGLED
85
Out of 100
#4 Overall 2-slice
Updated August 2026
KitchenAid Artisan 2-Slice
A die-cast design toaster with a motorised lift and precise browning to match the Artisan range
THE undig SCORE — 3 SOURCES, UNTANGLED
84
Out of 100
#5 Overall 2-slice
Updated August 2026
Russell Hobbs Toaster
The value pick — even everyday toasting with the essential modes at a budget price
THE undig SCORE — 3 SOURCES, UNTANGLED
82
Out of 100